Keywords
How to Cite
Abstract
Medieval Narva was the easternmost city of Livonia, falling within the purview of Lübeck law. Due to a range of political and economic factors, Narva’s legal system experienced dynamic transformations throughout the 15th and the first half of the 16th centuries. Alongside the Lübeck code, norms of customary, seigniorial, and merchant law were in effect. This study delves into the evolution of Lübeck law and the city’s judicial system in the context of legal pluralism and is contextualized within the broader framework of Russian-Hanseatic trade. The research suggests that Narva’s legal system was tailored primarily to serve the economic and political interests of the city’s leadership. Lübeck law, serving as the official regulatory system for its citizens, seamlessly incorporated foreign elements, which, over time, were perceived as integral. Lübeck’s political and economic approaches towards Narva in the late 15th and early 16th centuries left a mark on several developmental facets of the city. From the last quarter of the 15th century onwards, Narva had the recourse to appeal to Lübeck as its supreme judicial authority, even though Revel initially held this position. A detailed examination of the city’s evolving legal structures, influenced by trade and political dynamics, will likely intrigue historians focused on the Baltic region as well as those specialized in legal history.
References
Amelsberg, W. (2012). Die „samende“ im lübischen Recht. Eine Vermögensgemeinschaft zwischen Eltern und Kindern im spätmittelalterlichen Lübeck [The ‘Samende’ in the Lubeck Law. A community of assets between parents and children in late medieval Lübeck]. Böhlau. https://doi.org/10.7788/boehlau.9783412215729 (In German)
Angermann, N. (1990). Die Bedeutung Livlands für die Hanse [The importance of Livonia for the Hanseatic League]. In Die Hanse und der deutschen Osten [The Hanseatic League and the German East] (pp. 97–115). Nordostdeutsches Kulturwerk Verlag. (In German).
Angermann, N. (2001). Das Hamburgische Recht in Nordosteuropa [The Hamburg law of in Northeastern Europe]. In R. Schweitzer, W. Bastman-Bühner, & J. Hackmann (Eds.), Die Stadt im europäischen Nordosten. II. Internationalen Symposiums zur Deutschen Kultur im Europäischen Nordosten [The city in the European Northeast. The 2nd International Symposium on German Culture in the European Northeast] (pp. 65-73). n. p. (In German).
Angermann, N. (2006). Livland und Rußland [Livonia and Russia]. In J. Bracker (Ed.), Die Hanse: Lebenswirklichkeit und Mythos [Hanseatic League: Life and myth] (pp. 82–86). Verlag Schmidt-Römhild. (In German).
Bessudnova, M. B. (2013). “Unusual trade” within the Livonian-Novgorod goods exchange in the second half of the 15th century: setting of a problem). Novgorodika-2012: at the origins of the Russian statehood: the 4th international scientific conference, 285–293. (In Russian).
Bessudnova, M. B. (2019). “Unusual trade” as a transformation factor of the Hanseatic-Russian relations in the 15th – early 16th century. Scientific bulletin of the Novgorod State University, 5, 1–7. https://doi.org/10.34680/2411-7951.2019.5(23).1 (In Russian).
Bunge, F. G. v. (1844a). Die Quelle des Revaler Stadtrechts [Source of the Reval town law]. Verlag von Franz Kluge. (In German).
Bunge, F. G. v. (1844b). Nachrichten über das alte Archiv des Rathes zu Reval [News about the old archive of the Reval town council]. In F. G. v. Bunge (Ed.), Archiv für die Geschichte Liv-, Esth- und Curlands. Mit unterstützung der estländischen literarischen allerhöchst bestätigten Gesellschaft [Archive for the History of Livonia, Estonia and Courland. With the support of the Estonian Literary Society]: Vol. III (pp. 293–308). Verlag von Franz Kluge. (In German).
Bunge, F. G. v. (1874). Geschichte des Gerichtswesens und Gerichtsverfahrens in Liv-, Est- und Curland [History of the judicial system and court proceedings in Livonia, Estonia and Courland]. Verlag von Franz Kluge. (In German).
Bunge, F. G. v. (Ed.). (1855). Liv-, Esth- und Curländisches Urkundenbuch. Chap. 1. Vol. 2. [Civil register of Livonia, Estonia and Courland. Chap. 1. Vol. 2].
Bunge, F. G. v. (Ed.). (1867). Liv-, Esth- and Curländisches Urkundenbuch. Chap. 1. Vol. 5. [Civil register of Livonia, Estonia and Courland. Chap. 1. Vol. 5]. Verlag von Nikolai Kymmel. (In German).
Conrad, H. (1962). Deutsche Rechtgeschichte. Frühzeit und mittelalter [German legal history. Early period and Middle Ages]. Verlag C. F. Müller. (In German).
Cordes, A. (2000). Die Rolle der Handelsgesellschaften in der Arbeitswelt des spätmittelalterlichen Hansekaufmanns [The role of trading companies in the working world of the late Medieval Hanseatic merchant]. In J. Tandecki (Ed.), Die Rolle der Stadtgemeinden und bürgerlichen Genossenschaften im Hanseraum in der Entwicklung und Vermittlung des gesellschaftlichen und kulturellen Gedankengutes im Spätmittelalter [The role of urban communities and civil cooperatives in the Hanseatic City in the development and dissemination of social and cultural thought in the late Middle Ages] (pp. 33–48). n. p. (In German).
Cordes, A. (2022). Pragmatische Innovation. Die Neuerungen im lübischen Recht von 1263 bis 1294 [Pragmatic innovation. The innovations in Lübeck Law from 1263 to 1294]. Hansischen Geschichtsblätter, 140, 1-29. (In German).
Cordes, A., Höhn, P., & Krey, A. (2016). Schwächediskurse und Ressourcenregime. Überlegungen zu Hanse, Recht und historischem Wandel [Weakness discourses and resource regimes. Reflections on the Hanseatic League, law and historical change]. Hansische Geschichtsblätter, 134, 167-203. https://doi.org/10.21248/hgbll.2016.36 (In German)
Ebel, F. (2004a). Aufzeichnung von Ratsurteilen und Schöffensprüchen im Lübecker und Magdeburger Rechtskreis [Recording of council judgments and ‘Schöffensprüchen’ in the Lübeck and Magdeburg legal district]. In A. Fijal, H.-J. Leuchte, & H.-J. Schiewer (Eds.), Unsern fruntlichen grus zuvor. Deutsches Recht des Mittelalters im mittel- und osteuropäischen Raum. Kleine Schriften [Our friendly greeting before. German law of the Middle Ages in Central and Eastern Europe. Small fonts] (pp. 151–175). Böhlau. (In German).
Ebel, F. (2004b). Die Bedeutung deutschen Stadtrechts im Norden und Osten des mittelalterlichen Europa. Lübisches und Magdeburger Recht als Gegenstand von Kulturtransfer und Träger der Moderne [The importance of German city law in the north and east medieval Europe. Lübeck and Magdeburg law as an object of cultural transfer and a carrier of modernity]. In A. Fijal, H.-J. Leuchte, & H.-J. Schiewer (Eds.), Unsern fruntlichen grus zuvor. Deutsches Recht des Mittelalters im mittel- und osteuropäischen Raum. Kleine Schriften [Our friendly greeting before. German law of the Middle Ages in Central and Eastern Europe. Small fonts] (pp. 389–401). Böhlau. (In German).
Ebel, W. (1949). Hansisches Recht. Begriff und Probleme [Hanseatic law. Terms and issues]. Fleischer. (In German).
Ebel, W. (1952). Lübisches Kaufmannsrecht [Lübeck merchants law]. Der Göttinger Arbeitskreis. (In German).
Ebel, W. (1967). Der Rechtszug nach Lübeck [The legal recourse to Lübeck]. Hansische Geschichtsblätter, 85, 1-37. (In German).
Ebel, W. (1971). Lübisches Recht [Lubeck Law]. Verlag Schmidt-Römhild. (In German).
Frensdorff, F. (1872). Das lübische Recht nach seinen ältesten Formen [The Lubeck law according to its oldest forms]. Verlag von S. Hirzel. (In German).
Gąssowska, M. (2013). Narwa – inflanckie miasto na granicy państw i kultur w średniowieczu [Narva – an inflationary town on the border of states and cultures in the Middle Ages]. In J. Kowalski & T. Ratajczak (Eds.), Między panem a plebanem. Wieś, miasto, władza świecka i duchowna w kulturze średniowiecznej Europy [Between the lord and the vicar. Countryside, city, secular and spiritual power in the culture of medieval Europe] (pp. 357–368). Poznańskiego t-wa przyjaciół nauk. (In Polish).
Groth, C. (2016). Hanse und Recht. Eine Forschungsgeschichte [Hanseatic League and laws. A history of research]. Duncker & Humblot. (In German).
Hach, J. F. (1969). Das alte Lubische Recht [The old Lübeck Law]. Verlag Aalen. (In German).
Hansen, H. J. (2016). The History of Narva. Sata. (In Russian).
Hildebrand, H. (Ed.). (1881). Liv-, Esth- und Curländisches Urkundenbuch. Chap. 1. Vol. 7 [Civil register of Livonia, Estonia and Courland. Chap. 1. Vol. 7]. Verlag von J. Deubner. (In German).
Hildebrand, H. (Ed.). (1889). Liv-, Esth- und Curländisches Urkundenbuch. Chap. 1. Vol. 9 [Civil register of Livonia, Estonia and Courland. Chap. 1. Vol. 9]. Verlag von J. Deubner. (In German).
Hilderbrand, H., Schwartz, P., & Arbusow, L. (Eds.). (1900). Liv,—Esth- und Curländisches Urkundenbuch. Chap. 2. Vol. 1 [Civil register of Livonia, Estonia and Courland. Chap. 2. Vol. 1]. Kommissions-Verlag von J. Deubner. (In German).
Höhn, P. (2021). Kaufleute in Konflikt. Rechtspluralismus, Kredit und Gewalt im spätmittelalterlichen Lübeck [Merchants in conflict. Legal pluralism, credit and violence in late Medieval Lübeck]. Campus Verlag. (In German).
Höhn, P. (2022). Entscheidungsfindung und Entscheidungsvermeidung in der Hanse. Das Beispiel der Sunddurchfahrt um 1440 [Decision making and decision avoidance in the Hanseatic League. The example of the passage of the Sund passage around 1440]. In Wagner W. E. (Ed.), Entscheidungsfindung in spätmittelalterlichen Gemeinschaften [Entscheidungsfindung in spätmittelalterlichen Gemeinschaften] (pp. 91–137). Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht. https://doi.org/10.13109/9783666311345.91 (In German)
Jenks, S. (2005). Transaktionskostentheorie und die mittelalterliche Hanse [Transaction cost theory and the Medieval Hanseatic League]. Hansische Geschichtsblätter, 123, 31–42. https://doi.org/10.21248/hgbll.2005.158 (In German)
Jenks, S. (2015). Bishopsgate und die hansischen Rechte in London [Bishopsgate and the Hanseatic Rights in London]. Hansische Geschichtsblätter, 133, 1–40. https://doi.org/10.21248/hgbll.2015.80 (In German)
Johansen, P. (1933). Die Estlandliste des Liber census Daniae [The Estonia list of the Liber census Daniae]. Estländische Druckerei. (In German).
Johansen, P. (1941). Die Bedeutung der Hanse für Livland [The importance of the Hanseatic League for Livonia]. Hansische Geschichtsblätter, 65/66, 1-56. (In German).
Johansen, P. (1970). Der Prozeß des Erzbischofs Michael Hildebrand von Riga mit der Stadt Narva [The trial of Archbishop Michael Hildebrand of Riga with against Narva]. Zeitschrift Für Ostforschung [Journal of Eastern Studies], 19, 676–699. https://doi.org/10.25627/19701942465 (In German)
Kala, T. (Ed.). (1998). Lübecki õiguse Tallinna koodeks = Der Revaler Kodex des lübischen Rechts: 1282 [The Reval Code of Lübeck law: 1282]. Ilo. (In Estonian).
Kämpf, T. (2013). Das Revaler Ratsurteilsbuch. Grundsätze und Regeln des Prozessverfahrens in der frühneuzeitlichen Hansestadt [The Reval Council Judgment Book. Principles and rules of the trial procedure in the early modern Hanseatic town]. Böhlau. https://doi.org/10.7788/boehlau.9783412211493 (In German)
Karling, S. (1936). Narva. Eine Baugeschichtliche Untersuchung [Narva. Study of Architectural history]. Wahlström & Widstrand. (In German).
Kazakova, N. А. (1975). Livonian-Russian and Hanseatic-Russian relations. The end of the 14th – the beginning of the 16th centuries. Nauka. (In Russian).
Keller, О. B. (2014). Lübeck town law in the Novgorod office of the Hanseatic League. Herald of BSU. 3, 53–56. (In Russian).
Kivimäe, J. (2004). Medieval Narva: Featuring a Small Town between East and West. In K. Brüggemann (Ed.), Narva und die Ostseeregion (pp. 17–27). Narva Kolledz.
Kivimäe, J. (2020). Zwischen Reval und Lübeck. Die Narva-Frage in der Handelspolitik der späten Hansezeit [Between Reval and Lübeck. The Narva issue in the trade policy of the late Hanseatic period]. In Kreem J. & Sarnowsky J. (Eds.), ‘Hansisch’ oder ‘nicht hansisch’. Das Beispiel der kleinen Städte und Livlands in der Hanse [“Hanseatic” or “non-Hanseatic”. The example of small towns and Livonia in the Hanseatic League] (pp. 57–74). n. p. (In German).
Kleynenberg, I. E. (1970). The formation of agreements of sale and purchase and contracts of exchange in the Hanseatic trade. Auxiliary historical disciplines, 3, 137–139. (In Russian).
Küng, E. (2005). Narva linnaöigusest kesk- ja varauusajal [Narva’s town life in the Middle and Early Modern Ages]. In M. Ivask (Ed.), Narva Muuseumi Toimetised (Vol. 5, pp. 51–63). OU Sata. (In Estonian).
Mahling, M., Neitmann, K., & Thumser, M. (Eds.). (2018). Liv-, Est- und Curländisches Urkundenbuch. Chap. 1. Vol. 13 [Civil register of Livonia, Estonia and Courland. Chap. 1. Vol. 13]. Böhlau Verlag. (In German).
Ogris, W. (2012). Hand wahre Hand [Hand for hand]. In A. Cordes, H.-P. Haferkamp, H. Lück, D. Werkmüller, & C. Bertelsmann-Kierst (Eds.), Dictionary of German legal history (Vol. 2, pp. 698–702). Erich Schmidt Verlag. (In German).
Põltsam, I. (2003). Das Alltagsleben in den Kleinstädten Estlands im Mittelalter [Everyday life in the small towns of Estonia in the Middle Ages]. In Angermann N. (Ed.), Leben im Baltikum zur Zeit der Hanse: Zwölf Beiträge zum 12. Baltischen Seminar [Life in the Baltic States at the time of the Hanseatic League: Twelve posts to the 12th Baltic seminar] (pp. 157–175).
Selart, A. (2019). Die kleinen Städte Livlands und ihre Rolle in der oder für die Hanse [The small towns of Livonia and their role in the or for the Hanseatic League]. In J. Kreem & J. Sarnowsky (Eds.), ‘Hansisch’ oder ‘nicht hansisch’. Das Beispiel der kleinen Städte und Livlands in der Hanse [“Hanseatic” or “non-Hanseatic”. The example of small towns and Livonia in the Hanseatic League] (pp. 23–42). n. p. (In German).
Simon, U. (2001). Appellationen von Reval nach Lübeck – aus zurückgekehrten Akten des Archivs der Hansestadt Lübeck [Appeals from Reval to Lübeck – from files returned from the archives of the Hanseatic City of Lübeck]. In R. Schweitzer, W. Bastman-Bühner, & J. Hackmann (Eds.), Die Stadt im europäischen Nordosten. II. Internationalen Symposiums zur Deutschen Kultur im Europäischen Nordosten [The city in the European Northeast. The 2nd International Symposium on German Culture in the European Northeast] (pp. 47–64). n. p. (In German).
Süvalep, A. (1936). Narva ajalugu I. Taani- ja orduaeg [History of Narva I. Danish and Order period]. Postimehe. (In Estonian).
Tallinn city archive. (n.d.-a). F. 230. BB 52 I. 84 p. (In German).
Tallinn city archive. (n.d.-b). F. 230. BB 52 II. 54 p. (In German).
Tallinn city archive. (n.d.-c). F. 230. BD 8 I. 57 p. (In German).
Tallinn city archive. (n.d.-d). F. 230. BD 8 II. 66 p. (In German).
Yakunina, V. A. (2021). Narva under the Livonian Order: The Role of Bailiffs in Court System. Man. Society. Communication. European Proceedings of Social and Behavioural Sciences, 108, 1003‑1010. https://doi.org/10.15405/epsbs.2021.05.02.127
Yakunina, V. A. (2022). Narva of the 15th century in documents and materials. Yaroslav-the-Wise Novgorod State University. (In Russian).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.